SCO and ECO: Area-Based Crop Insurance Add-Ons
Two county-level options that sit on top of your farm policy and cover part of the deductible.
Most farmers who buy crop insurance choose a farm-level policy with a coverage level of 70 to 85 percent. That leaves a deductible of 15 to 30 percent, which is a large number on a big operation in a bad year. Two optional endorsements, the Supplemental Coverage Option, known as SCO, and the Enhanced Coverage Option, known as ECO, were designed to help cover part of that deductible, using an area-based approach instead of your individual farm results. They are useful tools, but they work differently from the policy underneath, and understanding the difference prevents surprises.
Area-based coverage in plain terms
A farm-level policy compares your own yield or revenue to your own guarantee. An area-based product compares the county's result, based on a published index, to a trigger. If the county falls below the trigger, everyone with the coverage gets paid, regardless of how their individual farm performed. That means two things. You can have a loss and receive no payment if the county does well, and you can have a good year and still receive a payment if the county does badly.
The benefit is that area-based products can be cheaper, because the insurer does not need to adjust individual losses and farms cannot influence the index, and they can pay quickly after the final data are published. The trade-off is basis risk, which is the gap between your farm and the county.
SCO: Supplemental Coverage Option
SCO is an endorsement that can be added to certain underlying individual policies, covering the layer of losses between the underlying coverage level and an upper limit set by the program. It pays based on county-level yield or revenue, not your own farm's.
Key points:
- Available with eligible underlying policies for specific crops, with eligibility rules that depend on the plan chosen and program participation. For some crops, the underlying plan needs to be yield or revenue protection. Check with your agent.
- Coverage band. It begins where your underlying coverage ends, and runs up to a program-set maximum. The upper limit has been raised by legislation in recent years, so confirm the current level with an agent or the RMA.
- Premium subsidy. SCO has a high premium subsidy rate set by the program, and the rate can change, so check current figures.
- Payment. Based on county revenue or yield compared to the expected county revenue or yield, scaled by your insured acres and the policy's value. Payments occur after final county data are available, after the harvest period, often later than farm-level claims.
- Interaction with other programs. Rules about eligibility for certain farm programs, such as those that provide price and revenue payments on base acres, have affected whether a farmer can buy SCO. Consult your agent and local FSA about the current rules.
ECO: Enhanced Coverage Option
ECO is a similar county-level endorsement that provides coverage for higher bands above the SCO band. Historically, it offered two levels, with coverage up to 90 percent and up to 95 percent of expected county yield or revenue. ECO requires an underlying individual policy for eligible crops and is subject to program rules that have changed over time. It generally carries a lower subsidy than SCO. Check the RMA for the current details.
Think of the coverage layers as a stack:
| Layer | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Your deductible | Farm losses you retain, under your underlying coverage level |
| Underlying farm policy | Individual coverage up to your chosen percentage |
| SCO | Area-based layer extending upward from your underlying level |
| ECO | Area-based layers extending higher, if purchased |
How payments work, with an example
Suppose a farm buys an underlying revenue policy at 75 percent and adds SCO, which in this example covers the band from 75 to 86 percent of expected county revenue. In a given year, the final county revenue index comes in at 80 percent of expected. The county has lost 20 percent of expected revenue, which is 6 percentage points below the 86 percent upper edge of the SCO band. The SCO indemnity equals the amount by which the county's revenue is below the upper limit, up to the width of the band, which is 11 points, times the insured value. In this case it is 6 points of the value of the crop. If the farm itself had a yield above average, it still gets paid, while a farm with a severe individual loss in a county with normal results would collect nothing from SCO.
These figures are for illustration only. Band widths, trigger levels, premiums, and payment calculations come from RMA rules for the specific year and crop.
When SCO and ECO may make sense
Area-based add-ons may be worth considering when:
- Your farm's results tend to track the county's, because you farm similar soils, practices and weather exposures, and not an unusual microclimate.
- You want to reduce a high deductible without paying for a higher individual coverage level, since higher levels can be costly or unavailable.
- You have a lender who prefers more coverage.
- Your county has had large widespread losses in the past, such as drought years.
- You want coverage that can pay for revenue declines driven by price, and your farm tends to follow regional price patterns.
They may make less sense when:
- Your farm differs strongly from the county, such as irrigated acres in a mostly dryland county, or a farm with special risks, such as hail or flood, that other farms in the county do not share.
- You farm in a county with limited data or a history of small index changes.
- Premiums are high relative to the likelihood of payment.
Run numbers with your agent. Ask for quotes with and without the add-on and for historical analysis. University economists, including those at farmdoc daily, publish analyses of SCO and ECO performance, useful for comparing against marketing plans.
Questions to ask your agent
- Which crops and plans in my county are eligible for SCO and ECO this year?
- What are the current upper coverage limits, premiums and subsidy rates?
- What are the sales closing and reporting dates, and are they the same as for my underlying policy?
- How does my county's history compare to my farm's history?
- Do these endorsements affect eligibility for other programs?
- When would payments be made, and how are they calculated?
- What is the total premium for the extra coverage, and how does it compare to raising my coverage level?
Add your answers to the crop insurance decision checklist, and compare costs with the farm insurance deductible comparison.
How SCO and ECO fit with a marketing plan and cash flow
Because payments depend on final county data, they may arrive months after harvest, so they are less helpful for immediate cash needs. Do not count on them to cover bills due in the fall. Keep a reserve or credit line. See how big should a farm emergency fund be and farm cash flow planning.
If you use forward contracts or hedges, area-based payments are not tied to your production, so they cannot be relied on to fill a shortage. Individual coverage remains the key protection. See how to write a crop marketing plan and revenue protection vs yield protection.
Other area-based programs
Area Risk Protection Insurance is a separate area-based product that serves as the underlying policy itself, rather than an add-on. Other farm programs, such as those administered by the Farm Service Agency, also use county or national benchmarks. See USDA disaster assistance programs explained and the FSA programs page.
Keep rules current
Crop insurance rules change frequently with legislation and RMA decisions. Details that were accurate last year may not be this year. Confirm dates, coverage bands, eligibility and subsidy rates before the sales closing date each year. See crop insurance for beginners.
Stay informed
Follow farm policy developments at FARM.FM Agribusiness and FARM.FM USA Today.
Frequently asked questions
Can I buy SCO or ECO without an individual policy?
Generally, these endorsements require an eligible underlying policy for the crop. Check eligibility with your agent for your crop and county.
Does SCO pay if my farm has a loss but my county does not?
No. Payments depend on the county index. That is the basis risk of area-based coverage.
Are SCO and ECO worth the cost?
It depends on your farm, county history, premiums and subsidies. Compare quotes and expected payments, and consider your cash flow and deductible risk.