Dairy Margin Coverage and Dairy Revenue Protection
Two federal tools for dairy farms, built on different logic and often best used together.
Dairy farms operate on a margin, the difference between milk price and feed cost, and both sides of that margin can move sharply. Two federal tools help manage the risk. Dairy Margin Coverage, or DMC, is a Farm Service Agency program that pays when a national margin falls below a coverage level you choose. Dairy Revenue Protection, or DRP, is a federally subsidized insurance product sold through crop insurance agents that protects against falls in revenue based on futures-linked milk prices. They are often confused, but they work in different ways, have different enrollment systems and complement each other. This article explains each and how they fit together. Program details change with legislation, so confirm current rules with FSA and an insurance agent.
Dairy Margin Coverage
How it works
DMC is administered by the Farm Service Agency. It compares a national all-milk price to a formula feed cost, calculated from corn, soybean meal and alfalfa hay prices, to produce a margin in dollars per hundredweight. If the average margin over a two-month period falls below the coverage level you selected, you receive a payment based on the difference and your covered production volume.
The key points are:
- National formula, not your farm. The margin uses national prices and a formula ration, not your milk check or your feed costs. Your actual margin can differ.
- Production history. Your covered volume is based on historical milk marketings, with an established production history, and adjustments for farms that began or expanded. There is a limit to the volume that qualifies for the lowest premium tier, with higher tiers at higher premiums, and the thresholds can change.
- Coverage levels. Producers choose a margin coverage level from low values up to a high level per hundredweight on the first tier of production, and a narrower range above. Higher levels cost more in premium.
- Premium and fees. There is an administrative fee and premiums that depend on the coverage level and tier. Premium rates have been set in law and may be subsidized for certain levels or for small producers.
- Enrollment period. Enrollment typically occurs annually in a set window, and producers may lock in coverage for multiple years under program rules at a premium discount, subject to current law.
- Payments. Made when the margin for a period is below your coverage level, and are not dependent on actual losses.
Because DMC is based on national averages, it is best viewed as catastrophic, low-cost protection and a floor against prolonged low margins. It was designed to be simple and accessible to farms of all sizes.
Strengths and limits
Strengths include low cost at lower coverage levels, no futures account, no margin calls, and no sales closing date tied to markets. Limits include basis risk between national margin and your own, a cap on the production covered at the best premium tiers, and payments that depend on the formula.
Dairy Revenue Protection
How it works
DRP is a livestock insurance product overseen by the Risk Management Agency and sold by crop insurance agents. It insures quarterly revenue for milk based on futures prices for Class III or Class IV milk or on component prices of butterfat, protein and other solids, and on expected production. You choose the following.
- Quarter or quarters of coverage, up to several quarters ahead.
- Class pricing or components. Class pricing relies on Class III and Class IV futures, while component pricing uses butterfat, protein and other solids.
- Coverage level, often ranging from 80 to 95 percent of expected revenue.
- Declared production. The hundredweights you expect to market during the quarter.
- Protection factor and rules. A weighting between the price and the revenue protection structure.
If the actual quarter's revenue, calculated using final futures-based prices, is below the guarantee, you receive an indemnity. DRP uses futures-based prices, not your own milk check, so your result may differ from the payment.
Cost and subsidy
Premiums are subsidized, with the subsidy depending on coverage level. Premiums are due after the quarter, so there is no upfront payment. This may help cash flow. Quotes are published daily and depend on the market's volatility.
Strengths and limits
Strengths include flexibility in quarter selection and coverage level, the ability to cover more volume than DMC's tiers allow, and a link to futures-based revenue protection that works with forward marketing. Limits include basis risk between the futures-based price and the milk check, reliance on an agent, and the need to learn the product. DRP does not protect against feed cost increases, except indirectly, because revenue protection does not account for costs. Ask an agent about related margin products, which have existed in some form for dairy.
Comparing the two
| Feature | Dairy Margin Coverage | Dairy Revenue Protection |
|---|---|---|
| Administered by | FSA | RMA, sold by crop insurance agents |
| What it protects | National margin over formula feed | Quarterly revenue based on futures-linked prices |
| Reference | National all-milk price and feed formula | Class or component futures prices and expected production |
| Covered volume | Based on production history, with tiers | Declared production for the quarter |
| Enrollment | Annual enrollment period | Daily purchase, subject to rules and quarter sales deadlines |
| Premium timing | Annual, with fee | Billed after the quarter |
| Protects against feed cost spikes | Yes, through the margin formula | No, only revenue |
| Basis risk | Between national margin and your margin | Between futures-based revenue and your milk check |
Using both together
Many dairy farms use DMC as a low-cost safety net on the first tier of production and add DRP for the production above the tier or for quarters when they want a higher floor. The two programs are not mutually exclusive, and farms often layer them with forward contracts from their handler. A sample layering approach might be:
- Enroll in DMC at a level that covers meaningful margin on the first tier.
- Use DRP for quarters in which cash flow is thinnest or when forward prices are attractive.
- Forward contract part of the feed supply or buy options on feed. See managing farm input cost risk.
- Keep a reserve for periods when neither pays. See how big should a farm emergency fund be.
How to decide
Gather the following before talking to FSA and an agent:
- Your milk production history and expected volume.
- Your mailbox price and feed cost per hundredweight, with a margin calculation. See milk price volatility worksheet and feed cost risk worksheet.
- Your cash flow, debt service and lender expectations. See farm cash flow planning.
- Your tolerance for risk and ability to absorb a downturn.
Test scenarios. For a 300-cow herd shipping about 75,000 hundredweight a year, a drop of $1.50 in margin means a reduction of $112,500 in annual margin. If a DMC payment covers $20,000 of that and DRP covers a further $30,000, the herd still carries the remaining $62,500, so reserves and cost control are essential. Numbers are illustrative only. Use the cash flow stress test and the farm stress test calculator to see the effect on your farm.
Related tools
DMC and DRP are not the only ways to manage dairy price risk. Forward contracts through your handler, futures and options and operational changes can help. See milk price risk: tools for dairy farms, futures contracts for farmers and options on futures for farmers. Livestock price insurance for other species is covered in Livestock Risk Protection explained.
Keep current
Dairy programs are updated by Congress and USDA, and eligibility, premium, production history and enrollment rules shift. Check the FSA programs page, the RMA and your handler. For news and stories, see FARM.FM Dairy and FARM.FM Agribusiness.
Frequently asked questions
Is DMC an insurance policy?
No. It is a Farm Service Agency program that pays when a national margin is below your selected level. DRP is a federal insurance product sold by agents.
Can I use both programs?
Yes. Many dairy farms use DMC for basic protection and DRP for additional coverage. Check current rules and compare the costs.
Does DRP cover feed costs?
No. It covers revenue based on milk prices and expected production. DMC includes feed costs in its margin formula.