Manure Pit and Confined Space Hazards
Hydrogen sulfide knocks workers down in one breath, and rescuers often become the next victims.
Liquid manure storage looks like an ordinary tank or pond. The danger is the gas. As manure decomposes without oxygen, it releases hydrogen sulfide, methane, ammonia and carbon dioxide. These gases can build up in pits, tanks, below-barn storage, transfer pits and low spots, especially when manure is agitated or pumped. At low concentrations hydrogen sulfide smells like rotten eggs, but at higher levels it dulls the sense of smell and can cause collapse in a breath or two. Confined space incidents on livestock farms have killed workers, farm owners and family members, often in groups, because people who tried to rescue the first victim were overcome as well. This article explains the hazards and the rules that prevent these tragedies. It is educational. Follow applicable regulations, and train with qualified professionals. See NIOSH and OSHA resources on confined spaces and agricultural operations.
What makes manure storage dangerous
Hydrogen sulfide
Hydrogen sulfide (H2S) is toxic and heavier than air, so it collects in low areas. Effects increase with concentration:
- At low levels, eye and throat irritation, headache and nausea.
- At moderate levels, severe respiratory distress and loss of sense of smell.
- At high levels, immediate unconsciousness, respiratory paralysis and death.
When manure is stirred or pumped, bursts of gas can be released rapidly. A pit that has been quiet may release a large amount of gas when agitation begins.
Methane
Methane is flammable and explosive and displaces oxygen. It is lighter than air, but it can collect in poorly ventilated structures. Sparks, open flames and electrical equipment can ignite it.
Carbon dioxide
CO2 is heavier than air and displaces oxygen, which can cause suffocation. It builds up in pits and enclosed spaces.
Ammonia
Ammonia irritates eyes and lungs and can be harmful at higher concentrations, especially in enclosed housing.
Oxygen deficiency
Spaces that are low in oxygen may not feel unusual until a person collapses. Oxygen deficiency can occur even without toxic gases.
Other hazards
- Drowning in liquid manure.
- Falling into pits through openings.
- Machinery such as agitators, pumps and PTO shafts.
- Electrical hazards.
- Structural collapse.
Where the hazards exist
- Below-floor manure pits in swine, dairy and poultry buildings.
- Outdoor concrete tanks and earthen lagoons, especially near pumping stations.
- Transfer pits, wet wells, sumps and manure pipes.
- Pump-out ports and agitation points.
- Low areas near storage during agitation.
- Other confined spaces such as silos, bins and tanks. See grain bin entrapment prevention.
The golden rules
- Do not enter a manure pit or tank. The best entry is none. Use pumps, remote equipment and outside tools to clean, inspect and repair whenever possible.
- Never enter alone. Even for a quick look.
- Never try to rescue someone without proper equipment and training. Call 911.
- Ventilate before and during any pumping, agitation or work.
- Keep people and animals out of the building during agitation, unless ventilation is sufficient and safe.
- Control ignition sources near pits and storage areas.
Safe agitation and pumping practices
- Plan the work. Check weather, wind direction and conditions. Use calm days for best dispersal, avoid inversions and keep animals and people out of areas that could receive gas.
- Remove people and animals from buildings with pits before agitation begins, and keep them out until gases have cleared. Increase ventilation with fans, open curtains and doors. If animals cannot be moved, maximize ventilation and follow veterinary advice.
- Start agitation outside the building if possible. Agitate from an exterior pump-out port rather than inside.
- Keep everyone upwind of the opening, and keep children away.
- Stay away from pit openings during agitation.
- Use gas monitors, such as personal four-gas detectors that measure H2S, oxygen, combustible gases and CO, and calibrate them regularly. A monitor should be worn by anyone who may be exposed. Know the alarm levels.
- Never rely on smell to detect hydrogen sulfide.
- Use proper equipment: pumps rated for the job, grounded and explosion-safe where needed.
- Maintain equipment and check hoses and connections.
- Have a communication plan. Use radios, phones and visual checks.
If entry is unavoidable
Treat any entry as a permit-required confined space entry and use a formal procedure. Elements include:
- Evaluate whether entry is truly necessary, and consider alternatives such as hiring a professional contractor with equipment and training.
- Lock out and tag out pumps, agitators and power.
- Ventilate the space with mechanical ventilation before and during entry.
- Test the atmosphere from outside with a calibrated gas monitor, at different levels, for oxygen, H2S, combustible gases and CO. Continue monitoring during entry.
- Use a self-contained breathing apparatus or supplied-air respirator for entry in atmospheres that are not safe. Standard dust masks and cartridge respirators do not provide oxygen and may not protect against high gas levels.
- Wear a full-body harness and lifeline attached to a retrieval system, such as a tripod with a winch, so that rescuers can pull the person out without entering.
- Station a trained attendant outside who stays in contact and never enters.
- Have rescue plans and equipment ready, including emergency services contacts. Many fire departments have confined space rescue teams, and local fire departments can be contacted in advance.
- Document the entry with a permit.
- Train all participants in advance.
Many farms choose to hire certified contractors for pit cleaning, repair and entry rather than build the expertise internally. This is often wise.
Emergency response
If someone collapses in or near a pit or tank:
- Call 911 immediately. Say it is a confined space emergency involving manure gas.
- Do not enter. Many multiple fatalities have occurred when rescuers followed a victim into a pit.
- Ventilate from outside if safe to do so, by running fans and opening doors.
- If the victim is attached to a lifeline, retrieve from outside.
- Provide first aid after removal from the hazard, including CPR if trained.
- Direct responders and give the best information about the location and gases.
Make sure responders know the location of the farm. See farm emergency contact plan.
Training and policy
- Hold a safety meeting for everyone, including family members and seasonal workers, before pumping seasons. Use the farm employee safety orientation.
- Post warning signs at pits, tanks and lagoons, including signs in languages workers use.
- Cover and secure openings with grates or covers to prevent falls and to keep children and animals out.
- Fence lagoons and storage areas.
- Include manure storage in your hazard survey. See building a farm safety program and the farm risk register.
- Check regulations on manure storage design, nutrient management and permits. See environmental compliance for farms.
- Review insurance coverage. See farm liability insurance guide and hiring farm workers: compliance basics.
Livestock and ventilation
Gases released during agitation can also kill animals. Pigs and poultry have been lost in large numbers. Ventilation capacity, backup power and monitoring are essential. See power outage preparedness plan and livestock mortality management. A failure of ventilation or power can create the same atmosphere inside buildings.
Checklist
- No entry into pits or tanks without a formal plan.
- People and animals out during agitation, or ventilation maximized.
- Personal gas monitors on, calibrated and used.
- Pumps and agitators locked out when working near them.
- Attendant and rescue plan for any entry.
- No rescue attempts without equipment.
- Warning signs, covers and fences in place.
- Training done annually.
- Emergency contacts posted.
- Professional contractors used when appropriate.
Stay informed
For farm safety news and stories, see FARM.FM Farming, FARM.FM Rural Life and FARM.FM News. For fresh air, FARM.FM Jokes is reliably ventilated.
Frequently asked questions
Can I smell hydrogen sulfide before it is dangerous?
At low levels, yes, but at higher levels it deadens the sense of smell, so smell is not a reliable warning. Use gas monitors.
Is it safe to enter a pit after it has been emptied?
Not necessarily. Gas and low oxygen can remain. Test, ventilate and follow confined space rules or hire a trained contractor.
Should I try to rescue a person who collapses?
Call 911 first. Do not enter without proper equipment and training. Most multiple-fatality incidents happen when rescuers enter.