Forward Contract vs Basis Contract for Grain
Two common ways to sell ahead, and what each one leaves open.
When an elevator offers to buy your crop before it is harvested, the offer usually arrives as one of a handful of contract types. Two of the most common are the forward contract and the basis contract. They sound similar and are often confused, but they lock different pieces of the price and carry different risks. Knowing which piece you are fixing, and which you are leaving open, is the difference between a contract that serves your plan and one that surprises you.
Quick definitions
Forward contract. Also called a cash forward or fixed-price contract. You agree to deliver a set quantity of grain during a set period at a fixed price per bushel. Both the futures component and the basis are locked.
Basis contract. You agree to deliver a set quantity during a set period at a fixed basis relative to a specific futures month. The futures price is not set yet. You choose when to set it, usually before a stated deadline, and the final price is futures plus the agreed basis. If you need a refresher on the term, see what is basis in grain marketing.
| Feature | Forward contract | Basis contract |
|---|---|---|
| Futures price | Locked | Open until you set it |
| Basis | Locked | Locked |
| Main protection | Falling prices and weak basis | Weak basis only |
| Main risk | Missing a later rally; delivery failure | Falling futures before you price |
| Best when | Price meets your target | Basis is strong and you want to price later |
How a forward contract works
Suppose in April an elevator offers $4.40 per bushel for corn delivered in October, 10,000 bushels. If December futures are $4.70 and the elevator's October basis is 30 under, the bid reflects that spread. By signing, you lock $4.40, regardless of where futures or basis go later. If prices fall to $3.90, you are protected. If they rise to $5.20, you collect $4.40.
This is the simplest form of price protection, and many farms use forward contracts for a portion of expected production. Because the price is fixed, you are exposed to production risk. If drought cuts your yield and you cannot deliver, you may have to buy back the contract at a loss or deliver from other sources. That is why plans limit pre-harvest sales, as described in how to write a crop marketing plan.
How a basis contract works
In the same example, you might instead sign a basis contract at 15 under December futures, which the elevator offers because it needs grain at harvest. You do not yet know the final price. You have 60 days to set the futures price, and the final price will be that futures price minus 15 cents.
If you set the futures when December is $4.90, the price is $4.75. If you wait and December drops to $4.30, the price is $4.15. The contract protected you against local weakness but did not protect you against a fall in futures.
Producers use basis contracts when they think basis is attractive compared to their records, but futures are lower than they would like. Locking the basis now and waiting on futures is a way to capture one without committing to the other.
Related contract types
Elevators offer several variations. Names differ by region, so read the terms.
- Hedge-to-arrive (HTA). You lock the futures price and leave basis open. This is the opposite of a basis contract. See hedge-to-arrive contracts.
- Minimum price contract. A buyer sets a floor price and gives you some upside. See minimum price contracts.
- Delayed price (deferred payment). You deliver now and price later. Tax treatment and credit risk of the buyer matter. Talk to a tax professional and check the buyer's financial condition.
- Price later contracts and rolling contracts. Terms for rolling delivery to a later month vary and can carry fees or adjustments.
What to read in any grain contract
A contract is a legal agreement. The cash grain contract review worksheet and the article on reading a grain contract go deeper, but these items cause the most trouble.
- Quantity and tolerance. Is the quantity exact or plus/minus a percentage? What happens if you deliver less?
- Delivery period and location. Where and when must grain arrive? Are there penalties for missing the window?
- Quality terms. Moisture, test weight, damage and foreign material, with schedule of discounts.
- Pricing deadline for basis contracts or delayed price. What happens if you miss it?
- Default and buyback terms. If you cannot deliver, how is the buyback priced? Many contracts set it at the market on the day of default, which can be costly in a rally.
- Rolling fees, storage charges and interest. Understand how they are calculated.
- Payment terms. When are you paid, and is payment guaranteed by a bond or state fund? Verify the buyer's licensing through your state agriculture agency.
- Assignment and who signs. Ensure that the person signing has authority.
Choosing between them
A few questions help sort it out.
What do your records say about basis? If you track basis with the basis tracking worksheet and the current bid is strong compared to history, a basis contract captures that strength. If it is weak, avoid locking it.
Is the futures price above your target? If yes, a forward contract or HTA may meet your plan. If not, a basis contract lets you wait.
How confident are you in your yield? Lower confidence argues for smaller quantities, whichever contract you choose.
Can you handle a margin call or a buyback? Basis and forward contracts do not carry margin calls, unlike futures, which is a reason some farms prefer them. See margin calls and hedging liquidity.
Real-world pitfalls
- Forgetting the deadline. Some contracts automatically set at the deadline, whatever the market is doing.
- Rolling without understanding costs. Rolling a basis contract to a later month can add spread charges that eat profit.
- Overcommitting. Selling 100 percent of expected production before planting is a bet that nothing will go wrong.
- Assuming insurance covers everything. Revenue insurance can help with a yield loss that lets you fill contracts, but policy rules matter. See revenue protection vs yield protection.
- Verbal agreements. Get everything in writing and keep a copy.
Example: three paths from the same April bid
A farmer expects to harvest 40,000 bushels of corn and plans to price 25 percent early. She compares three offers in April.
- A forward contract for 10,000 bushels at $4.40.
- A basis contract on 10,000 bushels at 15 under December futures, price to be set by August 15.
- A minimum price contract with a floor at $4.20 and upside participation.
She chooses the forward contract for 5,000 bushels because $4.40 is above her target, a basis contract on another 5,000 bushels because she believes the basis is strong, and keeps the rest unpriced. This is only an example, and your numbers will differ.
For market context while you decide, farm business news at FARM.FM Agribusiness and national headlines at FARM.FM News can help you understand what is driving futures. A sense of humor helps when the market goes the other way, and the FARM.FM jokes page is as good a place as any.
Frequently asked questions
Which is safer, a forward contract or a basis contract?
They protect against different things. A forward contract protects against price decline and weak basis but exposes you to missing a rally. A basis contract protects against weak basis only. Neither is safe if you cannot deliver the grain.
Can I cancel a forward contract?
Usually only by agreement with the buyer, and often at a cost tied to the market price on the cancellation date. Read the default terms before signing.
Do contracts affect crop insurance?
Contracts do not change a policy, but contract price can affect decisions about coverage levels and what you can afford to buy back. Discuss both with your insurance agent and your marketing advisor.