Margin Calls and Hedging Liquidity
A hedge that works on paper can still strain the checking account. Plan the cash before you place the trade.
The most common reason a sound hedge turns into a bad experience is not the market. It is cash. A farmer sells futures to protect a crop, prices rally and daily settlements pull money out of the margin account. The physical grain is worth more, but it sits in the field or the bin, and the broker wants a wire by tomorrow. This article explains how margin works, why rallies create margin calls on short hedges, how to size a liquidity reserve and what alternatives exist for farms that cannot carry the cash risk. It is educational, not trading advice. Futures involve substantial risk, and you should work with a registered broker and your lender.
How margin works
When you trade futures, you post a performance bond, usually called margin, rather than paying the full value of the contract.
- Initial margin is the deposit required to open a position. It is set by the exchange and broker, and varies with volatility.
- Maintenance margin is the minimum balance you must keep. If the account falls below it, you receive a margin call requiring you to restore the account to the initial level.
- Variation margin is the daily settlement of gains and losses. The exchange marks positions to market every day.
- Hedger versus speculator margins. Exchanges often set lower margins for bona fide hedgers than for speculators, if the account is properly classified. Ask your broker.
Margin requirements change when volatility rises, sometimes at the worst moment. Check current numbers with your broker and the CME Group.
Why rallies create cash problems for short hedgers
A farmer who sold futures to hedge has a short position. When prices rise, the futures position loses money, which the account must cover daily. Meanwhile:
- The value of unsold crop rises, but this is a paper gain until you sell.
- Grain still in the field cannot be sold.
- Grain in storage can be sold, but doing so may mean lifting the hedge and missing further changes.
This mismatch between cash out on the hedge and cash in from the crop is the core liquidity risk.
Example
A farmer sells 100,000 bushels of corn futures at $4.80. Prices rise to $6.00 during summer drought. The futures position has lost $1.20 a bushel, or $120,000. The farmer must deposit that, less any margin already posted, even though the crop is still growing. If the crop is poor, the farmer might have a smaller yield and a bigger problem. Crop insurance may offset some of the loss, but the payment arrives after harvest. See crop insurance for beginners and futures contracts for farmers. The numbers are illustrative.
In the fall, if the farmer sells the physical corn at around $6.00 and closes the futures, the net is around the original $4.80 price, but the $120,000 had to be financed for months, and interest is a cost.
Sizing a reserve
A planning approach used by many advisors is to stress test the position:
- Define the maximum price move. For example, a $1.00 to $1.50 rally in corn over the season. Historical price ranges are available from extension and exchange data.
- Multiply by quantity. For 100,000 bushels and a $1.25 move, the potential variation margin is $125,000.
- Add initial margin.
- Subtract available liquid funds. Cash, unused credit lines and near-term sales.
- Compare to your lender's willingness to fund. Ask in advance.
If the answer exceeds what you can fund, reduce the size of the hedge, use options or find another tool. The hedging margin call planning guide gives a worksheet, and you can test your farm with the farm cash flow stress test and farm stress test calculator.
Where the cash can come from
- Cash reserves. The simplest, but they compete with other uses. See how big should a farm emergency fund be.
- Operating line of credit. Ask whether the lender allows draws for margin, and whether the line has a sublimit or covenants that would be affected. Some lenders require hedging to be approved in advance.
- Dedicated hedging line. Some lenders offer one, based on collateral in stored or growing crops.
- Selling stored grain. Possible but may disrupt marketing.
- Insurance proceeds, which are slow.
- Family or partners, though mixing arrangements can strain relationships.
Do not discover your financing options during a rally. Talk to your lender in the winter. See farm financial records lenders expect and farm working capital explained.
Strategies that reduce margin call risk
Use options instead of futures
Buying put options requires a premium but no margin calls for the buyer. Your maximum cost is known. See options on futures for farmers and put options for grain marketing.
Use forward contracts or minimum price contracts
A forward contract with a grain buyer locks the price with no margin account. The buyer hedges and manages the margin. The farmer takes on delivery and counterparty risk. See forward contract vs basis contract, hedge-to-arrive contracts and minimum price contracts explained.
Hedge smaller portions
Hedging 25 to 40 percent of expected production is often easier to finance than 80 percent.
Hedge later in the season
Pre-harvest hedging carries the most weather and rally risk. Waiting until the crop is made reduces production uncertainty but may sacrifice price opportunities.
Use insurance as the base
Revenue protection insurance can cover price and yield declines without margin. See revenue protection vs yield protection. Some forms also provide a harvest price option that increases coverage if prices rise, which can help in rallies and drought years.
Spread purchases and sales over time
Scale-up selling spreads price and margin exposure. See scale-up selling for grain.
Roll or lift hedges thoughtfully
If a rally is unaffordable, lifting part of the hedge reduces further losses but converts the paper loss to a realized loss and leaves the crop unprotected. Decide in advance under what conditions you will do so.
Set up the plan before the trade
- Written plan. Quantity, price targets, margin reserve, who can authorize trades and exit rules.
- Broker agreement. Understand fees, call procedures, deadlines and what happens if you cannot meet a call. See choosing a marketing advisor or broker.
- Communication with your lender. Discuss limits and procedures.
- Margin call procedures. Know how and when you will be notified, and how quickly funds must arrive. Wires can take hours.
- Records. Track positions, margin and results. See farm income tax planning and risk.
- Family agreement. Agree on who decides.
Warning signs
- Hedging more than production or insurance can support.
- No identified funding for margin.
- Using the last of the operating line for margin during planting season.
- Making trades based on tips rather than a plan.
- Lack of understanding of how to exit.
- Emotional decisions after rallies.
Behavior and communication
Margin calls cause stress. Stress affects decisions. Have a plan, trusted advisors and open communication in the family. If financial pressure is affecting health or relationships, support is available. See farmer stress, fatigue and safety.
A checklist
- Calculate the stress margin need.
- Confirm funding sources and lender approval.
- Decide position size accordingly.
- Choose the tool: futures, options, forward contract or insurance.
- Set rules for adding, lifting or rolling hedges.
- Keep reserve funds available.
- Review weekly during volatile periods.
The futures and options education checklist covers the learning side.
Stay informed
Market conditions and margin rules change. Follow news at FARM.FM Agribusiness, FARM.FM News and FARM.FM Today. Educational material is available from the CFTC and CME Group. When margin calls get you down, FARM.FM Jokes needs no wire transfer.
Frequently asked questions
Do margin calls mean I lost money on the hedge?
On the futures side, yes, but if prices rose, the value of your physical crop rose too. The hedge is designed to offset those changes. The problem is timing of cash.
Can I avoid margin calls entirely?
Not with futures, but you can use options or forward contracts, which do not require margin from the farmer.
What happens if I cannot meet a margin call?
The broker can close your position, which may realize a loss at a bad time. Talk to your broker and lender early if you expect trouble.