Hedge-to-Arrive Contracts
A contract that fixes the futures price, leaves the basis open and has shaped a good many grain marketing stories, not all happy.
Grain buyers offer a menu of contracts. One of the most useful, and most misunderstood, is the hedge-to-arrive contract, often called an HTA or futures-only contract. It lets a farmer lock in the futures price for a quantity of grain now, without a margin account, and set the basis later. That sounds ideal when futures are high and local basis is weak, and in many cases it works well. But HTAs have a history of trouble when markets rallied and farmers who had rolled their contracts to later months faced big costs. This article explains how they work, what the risks are and what to check in the contract before signing. It is educational, not legal or financial advice. Have your lender or attorney review any contract you do not fully understand.
What an HTA is
In an HTA contract, you and the buyer agree to:
- A quantity of a commodity.
- A futures price and futures month, such as December corn at $4.80.
- A delivery period, often with a deadline for setting basis.
- Basis is not set at signing. You will set it later, according to the contract terms, often by choosing a date before delivery, when basis seems favorable.
The buyer typically hedges the position on the futures market on your behalf, which is why there is no margin call to you. The final price you receive is the futures price in the contract plus or minus the basis you set, less any fees.
Example
In March, a farmer contracts 20,000 bushels of corn for delivery in December with an HTA at $4.90 December futures. The local harvest basis is currently quoted at 40 cents under, but the farmer expects it might improve by summer, so she leaves basis open.
- In October, the basis is 25 cents under, and she sets it. Her price is $4.90 − $0.25 = $4.65.
- If the basis instead widened to 55 cents under and she had to deliver, her price would be $4.35.
So the HTA locked the futures component and left the basis open, which can help or hurt. A forward contract that locks both would have set a price of $4.50 in March. Numbers are illustrative.
Why farmers use HTAs
- Lock in a high futures price when basis is wide, and wait for basis to improve later.
- Avoid margin calls, since the buyer manages the hedge. See margin calls and hedging liquidity.
- Flexibility on delivery timing in some contracts.
- Simplicity compared with managing a futures account.
The risks
Basis risk
You carry the basis risk until you set it. If basis widens, you lose. Tracking local basis patterns helps, and the grain basis tracking worksheet gives a structure. See what is basis in grain marketing.
Production risk
If your crop falls short and you cannot deliver, you may need to buy back the contract at a loss if prices have risen, or pay fees. Coordinate contracted quantities with your insurance. See revenue protection vs yield protection and crop insurance for beginners. Contract only a share of expected production, and read what the buyer does if you default.
Roll risk
This is the trap. Suppose you hold an HTA for old-crop delivery and want to move it to a later month because prices have risen and you do not want to deliver at the lower contracted price. Many contracts allow rolling the delivery to a later futures month. The roll adjusts the futures price by the spread between months and typically charges a fee. If the market is in an inverted structure, with nearby futures higher than deferred months, rolling can cost you heavily, with the new futures price lower than the original. A farmer who rolls repeatedly in a rising market can end up with a contract far below market and large fees. Many farmers were hurt this way in the past, and some contracts led to disputes. Understand the roll terms, fees and effects on price before signing, and avoid rolling as a way to avoid taking a loss.
Counterparty and elevator risk
A buyer who goes out of business can leave you unpaid. Check the elevator's financial health and licensing. Many states license or bond grain buyers and warehouses, and state departments of agriculture can provide information. Consider asking about payment security and delivery terms.
Fees and service charges
HTAs may carry service fees, roll fees, minimum quantity requirements and late delivery charges. Compare with other contracts.
Tax and accounting treatment
Settlement timing affects income. Ask your tax advisor. See farm income tax planning and risk.
Comparing contract types
| Contract | Futures price | Basis | Margin calls | Typical use |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash sale | Current | Current | No | Immediate delivery |
| Forward contract | Locked | Locked | No | Price certainty for a future date |
| Basis contract | Open | Locked | No | Lock good basis, wait on futures |
| HTA or futures-only | Locked | Open | No | Lock futures, wait on basis |
| Minimum price contract | Floor with upside | Varies | No | Floor with upside, with a cost |
| Own futures hedge | Locked via broker | Open | Yes | Direct hedge |
See forward contract vs basis contract, minimum price contracts explained and futures contracts for farmers.
What to look for in an HTA contract
Use the cash grain contract review and read the whole document, especially:
- Quantity, grade and delivery window. Are there tolerances?
- Futures month and price.
- Basis-setting rules. Deadlines, who decides, how quickly, the default basis if you miss it.
- Roll provisions. Fees, spread treatment and limits.
- Default and nonperformance. What happens if you cannot deliver, and how the buyer calculates damages.
- Fees and charges.
- Payment terms and timing.
- Buyer's license and financial strength. Ask about bonding and insurance.
- Dispute resolution. Arbitration and venue.
- Assignment and rights.
If something is unclear, ask for written explanations, or have an attorney review. See reading a grain contract before you sign and farm business structures and liability.
Using HTAs responsibly
- Know your break-even and whether the locked futures price makes sense. See know your break-even before you sell.
- Contract a portion of production, based on a conservative yield and insurance.
- Track basis and set it according to a plan, not impulse.
- Avoid rolls unless you understand the full cost.
- Keep records of contracts and decisions.
- Check the buyer.
- Coordinate with your lender, who may want to see contracts in your marketing plan. See how to write a crop marketing plan.
An example of a plan
A farmer sets a rule: no more than 35 percent of expected production in HTA contracts before harvest, no rolls beyond one month and set basis by a fixed date unless it is at least as good as the five-year average for that time. She records each contract in a spreadsheet, and her insurance agent confirms coverage. This reduces the chance of being over-committed or trapped by rolling. The plan is illustrative.
Stay informed
Contract terms and markets change. For news and commentary, see FARM.FM Agribusiness, FARM.FM News and FARM.FM Today. For contracts of a lighter nature, FARM.FM Jokes has an excellent record of delivery.
Frequently asked questions
Is an HTA the same as a forward contract?
No. A forward contract fixes both futures price and basis. An HTA fixes only the futures price and leaves basis to be set later.
Why did HTAs get a bad reputation?
Largely because of rolling contracts in rising markets, which led to large costs and disputes. Understanding roll terms and fees avoids this.
Can I cancel an HTA?
Usually not without cost. You may buy it back at market prices or pay fees. Read the contract terms and talk to the buyer before committing.