Put Options for Grain Marketing
A put sets a floor under your price, and a clear plan decides when to buy, which strike to use and when to exit.
Many farmers want protection against a price drop but do not want to give up gains if the market rallies, and do not want margin calls if prices climb. A put option answers all three. You buy the right to sell futures at a chosen price, and the premium is your cost. This article is a practical companion to the broader explanation in options on futures for farmers. It walks through how to decide when to buy a put, how to choose the strike and expiration, how to handle the position as the season goes by and how puts compare with other tools. It is educational and not trading advice. Options can expire worthless and involve risk, so work with a registered broker or advisor and read materials from the CFTC and CME Group.
Start with your numbers
Before looking at option prices, know:
- Expected production, with a conservative estimate.
- Break-even price per bushel, including land, inputs, machinery, labor and interest. See farm break-even price worksheet and know your break-even before you sell.
- Target price you would be happy to lock in.
- Expected basis in your area and time. See grain basis tracking worksheet.
- Crop insurance coverage, since insurance and puts overlap. See revenue protection vs yield protection.
- Cash flow needs and lender requirements. See farm cash flow planning.
A put should serve a purpose in a written marketing plan, not be bought on impulse. The farm marketing plan worksheet helps.
When farmers buy puts
- Pre-harvest, to protect the price of the growing crop. Prices often have a seasonal tendency to be higher in spring and early summer in some years, though not always. See grain price seasonality.
- Stored grain, to protect against price declines while holding unpriced grain for a basis or carry gain. See grain storage and the market carry.
- After a rally, to protect gains while leaving room for more.
- When margin calls are a concern, because puts avoid them.
- When crop insurance does not provide enough price protection for a higher goal.
Choosing the strike price
The strike determines the floor. Typical choices include:
- At the money, near the current futures price. Highest protection and highest premium.
- Slightly out of the money, below the current futures price. Lower premium, with some price decline absorbed by the farmer. This works like a deductible.
- In the money, above the current futures price. Expensive, behaving more like a futures sale.
Floor calculation
Net floor price ≈ strike − premium + expected basis. Basis is typically negative, so it is subtracted.
Example: corn
In April, December corn futures are $4.90. A farmer with a $4.30 break-even and 40,000 bushels of expected production considers three puts:
| Strike | Premium | Futures floor (strike − premium) | Net floor with −$0.30 basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| $4.90 | $0.35 | $4.55 | $4.25 |
| $4.70 | $0.24 | $4.46 | $4.16 |
| $4.50 | $0.15 | $4.35 | $4.05 |
Compared with a $4.30 break-even, even the highest strike locks in a net floor slightly below cost, which is a sign that the farm needs to improve margins or find other tools. It also shows that a floor is not a profit guarantee. If the farmer wants a net floor above break-even, the options may need to be paired with higher-priced sales on rallies, cost reductions or insurance. Numbers are illustrative.
Example: soybeans
In March, November soybean futures are $11.50. A producer buys $11.00 puts for $0.40. The futures floor is $10.60. If prices fall to $9.50 by expiration, the put's intrinsic value of $1.50 offsets the loss, so the effective price is $9.50 + $1.50 − $0.40 = $10.60. If prices rise to $12.50, the put expires worthless, and the effective price is $12.50 − $0.40 = $12.10.
Choosing the expiration
Match expiration to the time you need protection.
- Options on December corn and November soybeans typically expire in the fall before delivery months, so they cover harvest pricing in many cases.
- If you hold grain beyond the option's expiration, you may need to roll to a later contract.
- Longer-dated options cost more because of more time value, but they decay more slowly per day.
- Pre-harvest weather volatility can raise premiums in summer, so buying before peak volatility sometimes helps, though timing is uncertain.
How to size the position
- Hedge only a portion of expected production, often 25 to 60 percent depending on insurance and risk tolerance, to avoid over-hedging.
- Remember that each corn contract covers 5,000 bushels and each soybean contract 5,000 bushels, so rounding matters.
- If revenue protection insurance is in force, remember that it already provides price and yield protection at a certain level. Coordinate with your agent so that you do not pay twice for the same protection. See crop insurance for beginners.
Managing the position
If prices fall
The put gains value. You can:
- Hold it until near expiration, capturing any remaining time value.
- Sell it and use proceeds, perhaps rolling to a lower strike to maintain a floor.
- Sell your cash grain at harvest, or store and sell later with the put's gain offsetting.
If prices rise
The put loses value. You can:
- Let it expire, accepting the premium as the cost.
- Sell it early to recover remaining value.
- Raise your protection by buying a higher-strike put, locking in some of the gain, a strategy sometimes called rolling up. It adds cost.
- Price more grain through other contracts at higher prices.
If prices go sideways
Time decay erodes value, which is the cost of waiting. Decide ahead of time how long you will hold.
Roll rules
Write rules before you buy: when to roll, when to sell, how much loss you will accept. Emotions are strongest when markets move sharply.
Puts compared with alternatives
| Tool | Cost | Upside kept | Margin calls | Protection type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Put option | Premium | Yes | No | Price |
| Futures hedge | Margin and fees | No | Yes | Price |
| Forward contract | Usually none | No | No | Price and sometimes basis |
| Minimum price contract | Embedded cost | Yes | No | Price floor |
| Revenue protection insurance | Subsidized premium | Partly | No | Revenue |
| Storage and wait | Storage and interest | Yes | No | None |
See minimum price contracts explained, forward contract vs basis contract and futures contracts for farmers for details. Insurance premiums are subsidized, so it is often cheaper than an equivalent put, while options are more flexible. Many farms use insurance as the base and options as an extra layer.
Common mistakes
- Buying without a plan or a break-even.
- Over-hedging compared with production.
- Ignoring basis.
- Buying too far out of the money and getting little protection.
- Holding until expiration without a plan, losing time value.
- Chasing the market after sharp moves.
- Not coordinating with insurance.
- Failing to record positions for taxes and review.
- Selling puts or other options without understanding the obligation.
Records and taxes
Keep confirmations, premium payments and results. Option premiums and gains are treated under specific tax rules for hedges, so ask a tax advisor. See farm income tax planning and risk.
Getting started
- Complete the futures and options education checklist.
- Open an account with a registered broker. See choosing a marketing advisor or broker.
- Paper trade for a season to learn.
- Buy a small position and track the results.
- Review at the end of the season.
Educational resources are available from farmdoc, AgManager and extension marketing programs.
Stay informed
For market commentary and farm business news, see FARM.FM Agribusiness, FARM.FM News and FARM.FM Today. For stress relief when the market gaps lower, FARM.FM Jokes has no strike price.
Frequently asked questions
Which strike price should I choose?
It depends on your break-even, premium cost and risk tolerance. At-the-money puts give more protection at higher cost, while out-of-the-money puts cost less but leave you with a deductible.
What happens if I never sell the put?
It expires. If it is in the money, it may be automatically exercised into a futures position at expiration, depending on the rules, so ask your broker how to handle this. Most farmers sell before expiration.
Do puts replace crop insurance?
No. Puts protect price on the quantity covered, not yield. Insurance covers yield and revenue losses. They work together.