Hedging

Choosing a Marketing Advisor or Broker

Fees, registration, track record and fit decide whether outside help adds value or just adds a bill.

Updated November 19, 2026 · 6 min read · Hedging and Marketing Plans

Marketing grain and livestock has become more complicated: futures, options, basis contracts, minimum price contracts, storage decisions and tax timing all interact. Many farmers decide to get help from a marketing advisor, a broker or both. Good help can bring discipline, market knowledge and time savings. Poor help can bring high fees, aggressive trading and losses that are hard to trace. This article explains the roles, how they are regulated, the questions to ask and the warning signs to watch for. It is educational and not a recommendation of any firm. Check registrations yourself through the regulators named below.

Roles: advisor, broker and others

Futures commission merchant and introducing broker

A futures commission merchant (FCM) holds customer funds and carries futures accounts. An introducing broker (IB) solicits and accepts orders but typically has the FCM carry the account. Brokers execute trades and may provide market information and recommendations, depending on the firm. Their income typically comes from commissions and fees on trades.

Commodity trading advisor and marketing advisory firm

A commodity trading advisor (CTA) gives individualized advice on futures and options trading for compensation. Some marketing advisory firms provide market commentary and strategy recommendations for farmers, often by subscription, and may manage hedging programs. Whether a firm must register depends on the nature of its services and exemptions, so ask.

Elevator and ethanol plant staff

Local grain buyers offer contracts and market information. Their advice can be useful, but their interests are tied to their company's merchandising.

Extension and university programs

Many land-grant universities offer marketing education and tools, usually free or low cost, and without trading recommendations. See farmdoc and AgManager.

Lenders, accountants and attorneys

They are not marketers, but they review how marketing fits financial plans, taxes and contracts.

Regulation and registration

In the United States, futures and options intermediaries are regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, with industry oversight by the National Futures Association. Both provide ways to check a firm's registration and disciplinary history. Before you sign anything:

  1. Ask the firm for its registration category and NFA identification number.
  2. Look the firm and individual up in the NFA's public database, called BASIC, and review any disciplinary actions.
  3. Check the CFTC's resources on fraud and complaints.
  4. Ask whether the firm is exempt from registration, and why.

Be skeptical of any firm that promises high returns with little risk, guarantees profits or pressures you to act fast. The CFTC publishes consumer advisories on commodity fraud.

What to decide first

Before shopping, define what you need.

  • Do you want education and market information, or trade execution, or a managed marketing program?
  • How involved do you want to be? Some advisors make recommendations and you decide, while others manage discretionary accounts. Discretionary authority means they can trade without asking each time, which carries added risk and should be approached with great caution.
  • What tools are you comfortable using? Futures, options, contracts and storage.
  • What is your budget?
  • Have you written a marketing plan? See how to write a crop marketing plan and the farm marketing plan worksheet. An advisor should help you carry out your plan, not replace your goals.

Questions to ask

  1. Registration and history. What are your registrations, and have you had complaints or disciplinary actions?
  2. Experience with farms like mine. What crops, sizes and regions?
  3. Services. What exactly do I receive: recommendations, execution, education, reports, contact hours?
  4. Philosophy. How do you approach risk, price targets, storage and basis? Does it fit my plan? Can you explain it simply?
  5. Fees. What are all of the costs: subscription, commission per contract, account fees, platform fees, performance fees, interest on balances?
  6. Conflicts of interest. How do you make money? Do you take positions that conflict with your clients'?
  7. Track record. Can you show actual client results, not hypothetical ones, with methodology and time period? Be aware that past results do not guarantee future performance.
  8. Communication. How and how often will you contact me? How quickly can I place an order?
  9. Margin and liquidity. What are margin requirements, call procedures and deadlines? See margin calls and hedging liquidity.
  10. Account structure. Where are my funds held, and are they segregated?
  11. References. Can I speak with current farm clients?
  12. Termination. How do I leave, and what happens to open positions?

Fee structures

StructureHow it worksConsiderations
Commission per tradeFee per contract bought or soldIncentive to trade more
SubscriptionMonthly or annual fee for adviceFixed cost, no direct trading incentive
Retainer or consultingHourly or flat fee for planningGood for plan building
Managed program feePercentage of assets or productionCheck what is included
Performance feeShare of gainsCan encourage risk-taking

Ask for the fee schedule in writing, and calculate the cost per bushel. A fee of a few cents per bushel may be worthwhile if it improves discipline, but not if it goes to churn. See futures contracts for farmers for how trades work.

Red flags

  • Guaranteed returns or "no-risk" claims.
  • Pressure to open an account quickly.
  • Reluctance to provide registration details or documents.
  • Unsolicited cold calls promising big profits.
  • Requests to send money to an individual or an unusual payee.
  • Vague fee explanations.
  • Discretionary trading without clear written authorization and controls.
  • Encouraging you to trade more than your production or financial capacity.
  • Poor responsiveness before you sign, which tends to get worse after.
  • Results that look too good, based on hypothetical or cherry-picked data.

Protect yourself

  • Read the account agreement and risk disclosure. Keep copies.
  • Keep control of funds. Never give a third party unlimited access to your bank account.
  • Review statements every month and compare to your records.
  • Set limits in writing for position size and loss.
  • Involve your lender and family. Lenders may require hedging policies. See farm financial records lenders expect.
  • Keep records of recommendations and decisions for taxes and review. See farm income tax planning and risk.
  • Do not delegate responsibility. You are accountable for your marketing, so understand every trade.
  • Report concerns to the CFTC or NFA.

Evaluating performance

Judge an advisor against your plan, not only against the market. Questions to review each season:

  1. Did the advisor help us stick to the marketing plan?
  2. How did our average price compare with break-even and with local market averages?
  3. What did we pay in total, including commissions and fees?
  4. Did the advice reduce stress and improve decision quality?
  5. Were recommendations explained clearly, with reasons and risks?
  6. Would we do it again?

If the answers are poor, change. Loyalty is not a marketing strategy.

When you may not need an advisor

Some farmers manage well on their own using forward contracts, scale-up sales and crop insurance, with education from extension. See scale-up selling for grain, forward contract vs basis contract and minimum price contracts explained. A simple plan with a local elevator and a few contracts may be enough, especially for smaller farms. Others use an advisor only for a specific tool, such as options.

An example

A mid-size grain farm wants help with options but not discretionary trading. The owners shortlist three firms, check each in the NFA database and ask for fee schedules. One firm charges per-trade commissions and encourages frequent trading, another sells a subscription with written recommendations and a third offers hourly consulting for plan design plus execution through a separate broker. The farm chooses consulting plus execution, writes a plan and uses the advisor as a sounding board. Results are reviewed each fall with their lender. The scenario is illustrative.

Stay informed

For market commentary and farm business news, see FARM.FM Agribusiness, FARM.FM News and FARM.FM Today. For advice that costs nothing and is worth about that, FARM.FM Jokes does not charge commissions.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a broker to hedge?

To trade futures and options directly, yes, through a registered intermediary. Forward contracts and minimum price contracts through your elevator do not require a broker.

How do I check whether a firm is registered?

Use the National Futures Association's public database and the CFTC's resources. Verify both the firm and the individual.

Should I give an advisor discretionary control?

Most farmers do not, and it carries added risk. If you consider it, get terms in writing, set limits and seek independent advice first.

Worksheets that go with this article

Grain Storage and the Market CarryPrevious articleHow to Write a Farm Biosecurity PlanNext article

Official information and verification

Program rules, dates and prices change. Confirm current details with the agencies themselves. These links are for independent verification, not endorsements.

Educational content only. This article is not insurance, legal, tax, veterinary, investment or safety advice. Talk with a licensed insurance agent, lender, attorney, tax professional, veterinarian or safety professional about your own operation.