Grain Storage and the Market Carry
Storing grain is a bet on the spread between harvest and later prices, with real costs ticking every month.
Every fall, farmers face the same choice: sell the crop at harvest or store it and sell later. The decision looks simple, but it hides several moving parts. Storage costs money in interest, shrink, handling, insurance and sometimes rent. Storage can also earn money if the market pays you to wait. That payment shows up in two places: the futures spread between a nearby and a deferred contract, and the basis improvement from harvest lows to spring or summer. Together these form the market carry. This article explains how to measure the carry, how to compare it with your costs, what risks come with stored grain and how to protect the storage return. It is educational, not trading advice.
What the carry is
In a normal market, deferred futures trade at higher prices than nearby futures, because storage has costs. The difference between months is a spread. For example, if December corn trades at $4.80 and the following July at $5.20, the market is offering a 40-cent carry over seven months, about 5.7 cents a month.
Basis also changes seasonally. Harvest basis is often weakest because supply is heaviest. It tends to strengthen as the year goes on. If basis improves from 35 cents under at harvest to 10 cents under in summer, that is another 25 cents of potential return. A storer who sells futures for deferred delivery and later sets basis can capture both the spread and the basis improvement. See what is basis in grain marketing and grain price seasonality.
Sometimes the market is inverted, with nearby prices higher than deferred, which signals tight supply and discourages storage. In that case, selling at harvest may be best.
What storage costs
Count every cost, because the real carry is net of costs.
| Cost | Notes |
|---|---|
| Interest | Money tied up in unsold grain, at your borrowing rate or opportunity cost |
| Commercial storage fees | Per bushel per month, or flat seasonal rates |
| On-farm costs | Depreciation, repairs, electricity or fuel for aeration and drying, labor and property tax |
| Shrink | Moisture loss and handling losses, usually measured in a percentage |
| Quality risk | Spoilage, insects, mold and discounts |
| Insurance | Property and stored grain coverage |
| Opportunity cost | The alternative use of cash, or the price you could have locked |
| Margin requirements | If hedged with futures |
Example
Grain valued at $4.60 a bushel, with interest at 8 percent a year, costs about 3 cents a month in interest alone. Add on-farm costs of 1 to 2 cents a month and shrink of 0.5 percent, or about 2 cents. Over seven months, total costs could approach 30 to 35 cents. If the market carry plus basis gain is 65 cents, the net return is about 30 cents. If it is 25 cents, you lose money storing. Numbers are illustrative. Use the grain storage decision worksheet with your own costs and current spreads.
On-farm versus commercial storage
On-farm storage gives control and flexibility, cuts harvest hauling and can capture carry for the farm, but requires capital, maintenance, management and safety attention. See grain bin entrapment prevention and grain bin safety risk review. Existing bins already paid for may justify storage at lower marginal cost. New bins must be justified over their whole life, and not only in a year with a good carry.
Commercial storage at elevators or warehouses avoids capital and may offer marketing options such as deferred pricing, but charges fees and involves counterparty risk. Check that the facility is licensed and bonded, and understand how storage receipts, title and insurance work. Some states provide indemnity or oversight programs, and the state department of agriculture can explain.
Managing the risks of stored grain
Quality risk
Grain must be dry, cool and monitored. Temperature cables, aeration management and regular inspection prevent spoilage. Quality losses can erase the carry. Consult extension and the grain handling guidelines of land-grant universities.
Price risk
Unpriced stored grain is still exposed to falling prices. Tools include:
- Selling futures against stored grain, locking the spread. See futures contracts for farmers.
- Buying put options for a floor with upside. See put options for grain marketing.
- Forward or deferred price contracts with a buyer for later delivery. See forward contract vs basis contract and hedge-to-arrive contracts.
- Scale-up selling over the storage period. See scale-up selling for grain.
Be careful with hedging liquidity. See margin calls and hedging liquidity.
Basis risk
If you do not lock basis, it may not improve as expected. Track historical basis patterns for your location with the grain basis tracking worksheet.
Cash flow risk
Stored grain is not cash. Make sure bills, loans and taxes are covered. See farm cash flow planning and farm working capital explained. Your lender may want to see storage and marketing plans.
Insurance and safety
Insure stored grain, and check limits, sublimits and perils. See farm property insurance gaps and wildfire risk for farms and ranches. Bin entry is one of the most dangerous tasks on a farm. See grain bin entrapment prevention.
Tax timing
Deferring sales into the next tax year shifts income. See farm income tax planning and risk.
How to decide
- Calculate your cost of storage per bushel per month using the worksheet.
- Check current spreads and basis quotes from your elevator and the futures market.
- Estimate the net return at several sale dates.
- Compare with selling at harvest and investing or paying down debt.
- Decide how much to store, based on bin capacity, cash flow and risk.
- Choose how to protect the stored grain, with sales, hedges or options.
- Record the plan and monitor.
Some years the market does not pay to store. In those years, harvest sales or forward contracts for harvest delivery may be best, and bins may be used for convenience rather than return. Unused storage has costs, but good decisions avoid storing at a loss just because the bin is there.
An example
A farmer with 60,000 bushels of on-farm storage compares options. A forward sale for harvest delivery pays $4.50. Selling July futures against the stored grain locks a July price of $4.95, and she expects basis to be 20 cents better by summer than at harvest. Her costs total 32 cents. Net return from storage is about $0.45 + $0.20 − $0.32 = $0.33 a bushel, or about $19,800 for the bin. She stores, hedges with puts to keep upside, monitors grain temperature weekly and reviews the plan monthly. If the spread had narrowed to 20 cents, she would have sold at harvest. The example is illustrative.
Stay informed
For market and farm news, see FARM.FM Agribusiness, FARM.FM News and FARM.FM Today. For a bit of humor that keeps without aeration, FARM.FM Jokes never spoils.
Frequently asked questions
Is storing grain always profitable?
No. It pays when the carry plus basis improvement exceeds storage costs and risks. In inverted or flat markets, selling at harvest may be better.
How do I lock in the carry?
By selling deferred futures or using forward contracts for deferred delivery, and then setting basis later or locking it. Discuss options with your elevator or broker.
What are the biggest storage risks?
Spoilage, price declines on unpriced grain, safety hazards and cash flow shortfalls. Plan for each.